When StashAway MENA launched Shariah Global Portfolios in the UAE in August 2025, it did the thing incumbents fear most: it published better numbers. No minimum investment against Sarwa's $500. Management fees of 0.2% to 0.8% against Sarwa's 0.85% entry tier. And a compliance disclaimer so direct it reads like it was written by a regulator rather than a marketer. One year on, here is our full assessment.
Ready to compare halal options?
What the product is
Four globally diversified portfolios at different risk levels, measured by StashAway's Risk Index at 16%, 22%, 30% and 36% (Moderate through Very Aggressive), blending Shariah-compliant equity ETFs, global sukuk ETFs and gold. Allocation decisions run through ERAA, the firm's economic-regime asset allocation framework, with automatic re-optimisation as conditions change. The operating entity is StashAway Management (DIFC) Limited, regulated by the DFSA under licence F006312. Base currency is USD, there is no lock-in, and the recommended horizon is three years or longer.
The numbers so far
From the August 2025 launch through the end of 2025, the portfolios returned 9.3% on average in USD. Composite five-year historical returns of the underlying allocations ranged from 7.5% to 13.5% annualized to 31 December 2025. Treat those two figures very differently: the 9.3% is live but covers months, not years; the composites are backtests of the underlying ETFs, not portfolio history. StashAway publishes both with dates and methodology, which is more than most competitors do, but a short live record is a short live record. Underlying fund expenses average 0.4%, so all-in costs run roughly 0.6% to 1.2% depending on your tier.
The most honest disclaimer in the market
StashAway states that its portfolios are labelled Shariah-compliant based solely on the underlying ETFs' certification by their issuers or fund managers, that it does not independently certify, verify or guarantee compliance, and that customers in doubt should consult a qualified Shariah advisor. No entity-level Shariah Supervisory Board exists for the DIFC business; the Malaysian affiliate's arrangement with Masryef Advisory is not stated to cover the UAE entity. We grade this candor positively, and it is partly why the product earns a B+ on our Halal Money Index: the labelling matches the reality. But understand what the reality is. The compliance chain stops at the ETF issuers' boards. There is no purification tooling and no zakat support; both remain your own workstream, as they do at Sarwa.
Using it well in practice
Because there is no minimum and no lock-in, the cheapest way to evaluate StashAway is to run it: fund a small amount, pick the risk level whose drawdown you could genuinely sit through, and set a recurring transfer. The four risk levels map to real differences in composition, with the Moderate portfolio leaning harder on sukuk and gold while Very Aggressive concentrates in screened equities; choosing by projected return alone is the classic error, since the investor who abandons an aggressive portfolio in a bad quarter ends up poorer than the one who held a balanced one throughout. The ERAA framework will shift allocations as economic regimes change, which means your portfolio's contents are not static; read the re-optimisation notices rather than deleting the emails, because they tell you what you own.
For AED earners, note the workflow: contributions convert to USD on the way in. The dirham's dollar peg makes this mostly a mechanical step rather than a risk, but conversion costs and timing exist, and returns are reported in USD, so measure performance in the currency you actually spend.
Strengths and weaknesses
- Strength: zero minimum makes this the lowest barrier to managed halal investing in the UAE. AED 200 works.
- Strength: the 0.8% fee ceiling undercuts the incumbent, and the rate drops toward 0.2% at scale.
- Strength: four clearly specified risk levels beat vague conservative-to-aggressive labels.
- Weakness: live UAE track record only dates from August 2025.
- Weakness: no local human advisory layer to speak of; this is a product for self-service investors.
- Weakness: USD base currency introduces a currency conversion step for AED earners, though the dirham peg blunts the risk.
The fee mathematics over a decade
Fees compound exactly the way returns do, in reverse. Take AED 100,000 growing for ten years. The difference between an all-in cost of 1.05% and one of 0.9% sounds trivial, but it is roughly AED 2,000 of terminal wealth on that single starting balance, before counting the same drag on every subsequent contribution. Scale the balance or the horizon and the gap widens into real money. This is why we treat published fee schedules as a first-class feature rather than fine print, and why StashAway's tiering down to 0.2% at scale matters more than its launch-year returns. No platform controls what markets return; every platform controls what it charges. Judge them hardest on the number they can actually promise.
Compare providers in your state
See side-by-side comparisons of Shariah-compliant products, or let our matcher recommend the best options for your situation.
Verdict
For a self-directed UAE investor comfortable reading fund certifications, StashAway's Shariah portfolios are now the strongest default in managed halal investing: cheapest, most transparent about performance and compliance, and frictionless to start. Sarwa still wins on operating history and human advice, and stock-pickers should look at baraka instead. The full three-way comparison is in our halal robo-advisor guide, and the wider field, including sovereign sukuk and National Bonds, lives on the investing hub. Whichever platform you choose, remember the sentence StashAway itself effectively wrote: the halal label is only as strong as the fund certifications behind it.